Tony's Pier is a casual, family-friendly seafood spot on City Island that has been a local favorite for decades. It's praised for its generous portions, flavorful seafood (especially fried options), and a relaxed, classic waterfront vibe. While most reviews are positive, some mention issues with specific dishes being over-seasoned or not hot enough, and the cash-only policy with ATM fees is a drawback for some. The long-term, loyal staff and the owner's personable nature are frequently highlighted as positive aspects.
May differ from your actual experience.
Sign in with your SkyPhone account to post (also available in the app)